Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu
Welcome to Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, where pizza is crafted with passion and tradition. Located at 1217 Bay Rd, Webster, NY, this charming pizzeria is a beacon for those seeking authentic flavors and a welcoming atmosphere. Patrons rave about the consistently delicious pizza, noted for its rich sauce, generous cheese, and perfectly cooked pepperoni. Many have discovered their new favorite pizza spot after countless disappointments elsewhere.
- Service: The friendly and professional staff, exemplified by team member Amy, create a warm dining experience.
- Atmosphere: Salvatore's offers a clean, family-oriented environment, making it ideal for casual dining.
- Value: Affordable pricing and attractive weekly specials ensure great value for your money.
Whether dining in or carrying out, Salvatore's is committed to delivering pizza perfection that keeps customers returning for more.
APPETIZERS
Fries
Regular fresh cut style, Sweet Potato Fries, or Home Fries
Pizza Fries
Covered with pizza sauce & melted mozzarella
Loaded Fries
Covered with chili, bacon & melted cheddar cheese
Onion Rings
Thick cut beer battered onion rings
Garlic Bread
Giant loaf with melted mozzarella cheese
Hot Soup
Grandma Carmella’s Soup of the Day
Chili
(Seasonal) Our same recipe since 1978
Fried Mushrooms
Battered mushrooms • choice of one sauce
Chicken Fingers
(2pc.) With blue cheese & fries, choice of wing sauce
Mozzarella Sticks
(5pc.) Battered mozzarella • tomato sauce
Wing Mac Snack
(5pc.) Wings with mac salad and bread
Pizza Logs
(4pc.) With mozzarella, pepperoni & tomato sauce
Sausage Slingers
Chunks of Italian sausage, choice of wing sauce
Fried Calamari
Flash fried breaded calamari • side of tomato sauce
Buffalo Calamari
Choice of wing sauce with blue cheese
Sicilian Calamari
Kalamata olives, asiago cheese & peppers
Shrimp
10pc Breaded Shrimp tossed in sauce choice
Medium 12” (8 pcs)
Large 16” (16 pcs)
Thin NY 19” (8 pcs)
Salvatore’s Giant Sheet (32 pcs)
SuperSliceTM
1/4 of a Large Pizza! Double mozzarella or mozzarella & pepperoni
Specialty SuperSliceTM
Chef’s special. One of our Specialty pizzas
SuperSliceTM Combo
With 20 oz. soda & choice of chips or cookie
SuperSliceTM & Wing Combo
SuperSlice with 5 pc. wings & choice of sauce
MEAT TOPPINGS
Pepperoni, Old Fashioned Pepperoni, Beef Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Grilled Chicken, Meatballs, Baked Ham, Bacon, Genoa Salami, Ham Cappicola, Shaved Steak, Anchovies
CHEESE TOPPINGS
Mozzarella, Cheddar, Blue Cheese, Asiago, Ricotta, Sliced Swiss, Sliced American, Sliced Provolone, Vegan Cheese* (*2x charge)
VEGETABLE TOPPINGS
Mushrooms, Diced Onions, Banana Peppers, Red Pepper Strips, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Sliced Tomato, Artichokes, Spinach, Eggplant, Broccoli, Pineapple
SAUCE BASE
Our Famous Pizza Sauce, Pasta Sauce (Vegan), Pesto Sauce, Alfredo Sauce, Garlic & Oil Sauce, Any Wing Sauce Base
THIN THIN PIZZA
Individual 12”, extremely thin, European style pizza on wheat dough with mozzarella & one topping
GLUTEN-FREE PIZZA
Individual 12” thin pizza on gluten-free dough with mozzarella
GIANT CALZONE
Pizza dough, stuffed and folded in half. Mozzarella and choice of 2 pizza toppings with 4 oz. pasta sauce
CAULIFLOWER CRUST PIZZA
12” Cauliflower Crust with mozzarella. Keto Friendly!
*New* Pizza Bowl!
"No Dough Pizza" Sauce, Cheese & 3 Toppings. Keto Friendly!
Make Your Own Pizza Kit!
With Lots of Mozzarella & 1 Topping
FAMOUS PIZZA
SPECIALTY PIZZA
Salvatore’s Supreme PizzaTM
Sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, green peppers, onions & olives
The Salvatore PizzaTM
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms & giant Italian sausage
Linda Da’ Veggie PizzaTM
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, onions, green peppers, mushrooms & olives
Chicken Charlie PizzaTM
Blue cheese base, choice of wing sauce on chicken fingers & mozzarella
The Breath Mint PizzaTM
OUR GARLIC PIZZA, olive oil base, garlic, onions, tomatoes & mozzarella
Fred's Meat Market (Meathead PizzaTM)
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs & bacon
Steak Boomba PizzaTM
Tomato sauce or Sweet Country Sauce, steak, red peppers, onions & mozzarella
Alfredo- Not My Brother PizzaTM
Alfredo sauce base, grilled chicken, artichokes, red peppers, olives, & asiago
SoccerSam’s Low Fat PizzaTM
NO MOZZARELLA, tomato sauce, onions, green peppers & mushrooms.
Uncle Rico’s BBQ Chicken PizzaTM
BBQ sauce base, grilled chicken, red peppers, onions covered with cheddar
Mama Toni’s Plate PizzaTM
Salvie Plate beef hot sauce base, hamburger, fries, onions, mac salad & cheddar
The Taco Pizza Since 1978TM
Salsa sauce, cheddar cheese, onions, seasoned beef, lettuce, tomato & sour cream
*NEW* Love Holly Pizza
Garlic olive oil base, lots of mozzarella, artichokes, roasted red peppers, banana peppers. Named after Holly Anderson, President of The Breast Cancer Coalition.
Breakfast PizzaTM (Meat or Veggie)
Eggs, cheddar and mozzarella. Veggie: Onion, peppers & mushrooms. Meat: Sausage, ham & bacon. (Pre-Order, Pre-Pay)
Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings
SERVED WITH BLUE CHEESE & CHOICE OF WING SAUCE* *Wing Sauces: NEW! Van's Jerk Sauce, Garlic Parmesan, Mild Buffalo Wing Sauce (Spicy), Hot Buffalo Wing Sauce (It’s Hot!), Sweet Country Style (Mild & Sweet), BBQ Sauce
Wing Mac Snack
(5pc.) Wings with mac salad & bread
Sweet Country Breaded Wings
(10pc.) Rochester style
Extras
*Wing Sauces: NEW! Van's Jerk Sauce, Garlic Parmesan, Mild Buffalo Wing Sauce (Spicy), Hot Buffalo Wing Sauce (It’s Hot!), Sweet Country Style (Mild & Sweet), BBQ Sauce
WINGS & BONELESS
SALVATORE’S CHICKEN
Breaded Chicken Sandwich
With fresh cut style fries and custom dressed
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
With fresh cut style fries and custom dressed
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Breaded Chicken, choice of sauce & custom dressed w/ fries
Chicken Fingers (2pc)
Choice of sauce, blue cheese & fresh cut style fries
Chicken Fingers (5pc)
Choice of sauce, blue cheese & fresh cut style fries
Extras
Wing Sauces: Mild or Hot Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Country, Garlic Parm, Van’s Jerk Sauce & Chef Special Sauces
COLD SUBS
Italian Assorted, Roast Beef, Baked Ham, Turkey Breast, Genoa Salami, Tuna Fish, Ham Cappicola, Cheese Sub, Veggie Sub
HOT SUBS
Shaved Steak, Meatball, Italian Sausage, Pizza Sub, BLT, Eggplant Parm, Chicken Parm, Grilled Chicken, Chicken Finger, Buffalo Chicken, Hamburger Sub
CUSTOM MADE SUB & WRAP ITEMS (No Charge Items)
Choice of Cheese, Shredded Lettuce, Sliced Tomato, Sliced Onions, Banana Peppers, Roasted Peppers, Hellmann’s Mayo, Italian Dressing, French’s Mustard, Spicy Mustard, Honey Mustard, Pickles, Horseradish, Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mushrooms
Extras
Extra Cheese, Meat, Bacon, Mushrooms, Coleslaw, Extra Anything!
SUBS • WRAPS
SPECIALTY WRAPS
Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken, romaine, asiago cheese & Caesar dressing
Cajun Chicken
Sliced Cajun chicken, romaine, tomatoes & Mexican ranch dressing
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken fingers tossed with wing sauce, romaine, tomatoes & blue cheese
Baked Pasta with Mozzarella
Pasta choice & tomato sauce
Pasta & Meatballs
Pasta choice & tomato sauce
Stuffed Shells
Ricotta filled shells, mozzarella & tomato sauce
Eggplant Parm
Fried eggplant with mozzarella, sauce & pasta
Chicken Parm
Chicken cutlet with mozzarella, sauce & pasta
Grilled Chicken Parm
Grilled with mozzarella, tomato sauce & pasta
Haddock Parm
Fried Haddock with mozzarella, tomato sauce & pasta
Extras
All Dinners Include a Loaf of Garlic Bread Choice of Pasta: Spaghetti or Penne
ITALIAN DINNERS
PASTA SIDES
Pasta Sides
New Meatball Mania
Best Meatballs in Town! Meatball Sauce: Tomato, Alfredo, Pesto, Blue Cheese or Sweet Country
1/3 lb. Burger
Cheeseburger
Italian Burger
Salvie Burger
BBQ Burger
Blue Cheeseburger
Swiss Burger
Mushroom Burger
Double Burger
Double Cheeseburger
Salvie Plates
Salvie Plate Options: Hot Dog, Hamburger, Cheeseburger, Italian Sausage, Chicken Fingers, Grilled Chicken, Shaved Steak, Fish Fry Plate, Grilled Veggie Topped With: Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Hot Sauce Salvie Plates Include Choice...
Zweigle’s Red Hot
PUB BURGERS
SALVIE PLATES
Hot Dog
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Cheeseburger, Hamburger
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Italian Sausage
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Chicken Fingers
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Grilled Chicken
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Shaved Steak
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Fish Fry Plate
Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Grilled Veggie
Grilled Peppers, Onions & Mushrooms. Topped with Fresh Diced Onions & Salvie Plate Famous Beef Hot Sauce. Plates Include Choice of 2 sides: Mac Salad, Baked Beans or Potato Choice.
Big Bertha’s Fish Sub
Fried Haddock on large sub bread custom dressed
Haddock Fish Fry
11 oz. Haddock, fries, coleslaw or mac salad, roll & tartar
Haddock Parmesan
With tomato sauce, melted mozzarella & side of pasta
Shrimp Dinner
10pc. breaded shrimp, fresh cut style fries & choice of two sauces
Salvatore Style Shrimp Dinner
10pc. Covered w/ Sweet Country Sauce, a side of mac salad & fries
Fried Calamari
Flash fried breaded calamari served with side of tomato sauce
Buffalo Calamari
Fried breaded calamari with choice of wing sauce & blue cheese
Sicilian Calamari
Kalamata olives, asiago cheese, peppers & Balsamic Italian
IT’S FISHALICIOUS
FRESH SALADS
Macaroni Salad
Made with Hellmann’s Mayonnaise
Side Salad
Romaine mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers & onions
Tossed Salad
Romaine mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers & onions
Tuna Topped Salad
Tossed salad covered with tuna fish made with Hellmann’s mayo
Caesar Salad
Tossed salad, mushrooms, croutons, bacon, asiago & Caesar dressing
Antipasto Salad
Tossed salad, ham, provolone, salami, pepperoni, pepperoncini & black olives
It’s Greek to Me Salad
Tossed salad with feta cheese, kalamata olives & Greek dressing
Grilled Chicken Salad
Tossed salad with sliced grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Tossed salad with chicken fingers covered with mild wing sauce & cheddar
Cajun Chicken Salad
Tossed salad with sliced grilled Cajun chicken breast & cheddar
Calamari Salad
Tossed salad covered with fried breaded calamari
Buffalo Calamari Salad
Tossed salad covered with fried calamari, choice of wing sauce & blue cheese
Sicilian Calamari Salad
Tossed salad covered with fried calamari, asiago cheese, Kalamata olives, peppers and Balsamic Italian dressing
Extras
Dressing Choices: Italian, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Caesar, Country French, Honey Mustard, Greek Dressing, Thousand Island, Lite Italian, Fat Free Raspberry Vinaigrette
Cookie (Fresh Baked)
4 Pack Cookies
2 Pack Cannoli
Italian Cheesecake
Carrot Cake
Peanut Butter Pie
Chips & More
Ask server for variety & price
DELICIOUS DESSERTS
SALVATORE’S DRINKS
Various Drinks
(Plus tax & deposit) Prices may vary per location